[header]
weblog photography photoblog contact site map
Login Login

Register

[About me] About the author
[Me]

Geek and nerd Joe D has in the past studied genetics, molecular and cell biology, worked in cancer research, and made contemptuous amounts of money from incompetently composed photographs. The views expressed on this weblog are not his own; rather, he stole them from you through mind invasion.

more...

RSS feeds Syndicate

Subscribe to the weblog:

RSS 2.0 Atom

Add to Google Subscribe with Bloglines

Subscribe to the photoblog:

RSS Atom

Add to Google Subscribe with Bloglines

List of RSS feeds

Framing science: everything is a national security issue

I have subscribed to EurekAlert's feed of biological sciences press releases for a few years now, and they occasionally show up in the miniblog in the right-hand column of the front page. The press releases are almost universally written by dedicated PR officials at universities, learned societies, and not-so-learned societies. I get the impression that the PR officials have minimal interaction with the scientists involved, and the results of this enterprise are almost invariably worth more in comedy currency than scientific (the reason all of these links are from scienceblogs.com is simply because I ran out of words to link before I could look for other sources of mockery). We criticise newspapers for their poor grasp of scientific developments, and ever poorer communication of them, but actually, they seem pretty good at faithfully reproducing some of the nonsense in press releases (I would have a go at linking all the words in that sentence to bad newspaper coverage of science, but it would be too easy just to link to the past fortnight's editions of the Daily Express).

Alongside the accidentally absurd are the deliberately overblown. It's an unfortunate effect of the internal market in science that sometimes, the survivor is not the one who does the best and most important work, but the one who shouts the loudest about how good and important their work is. The item that inspired this particular outpouring is this, from yesterday: New use for stem cells found in war on terrorism. That's some hefty framing.


[Edit] Edit | [Delete] Delete | [History] History | [Version] Last edited by {{{user_full}}}, 2007-09-26 17:24:38 | [Views] Viewed 10206 times | [del.icio.us] [Digg thins] [Reddit] [Magnolia] [Spurl] [Searchles]


If you've written something relevant to this page elsewhere on the web you can notify readers of this page with a trackback. If you have a weblog, chances are your software has an easy built in way to send trackbacks. If your software doesn't let you send trackbacks, this technical specification may help. And if that sounds too much like hard work, just leave a comment!

Send trackbacks to http://www.cotch.net/trackbacks.php?ns=blog&fn=20070926_1723

Name:

Email:

URL:

Comment:

Wikicode:

  • Links: [[page]] or [[namespace:pagename|link title]]
  • External links: [[http://www.example.com|link title]]
  • Start a new line with an * or a # to make a list.

{{{displayname}}}

{{{flag}}} Earth

Oh wow! I hit "Save" on this item, and went to make more tea, only to hear Eddie on BBC Radio 4's PM programme faithfully reproducing this press release!

Posted at 2007-09-26 17:44:25 - [Del]


Creative Commons License Best Viewed With Any Browser! Valid HTML 4.0 Valid CSS Powered by Apache Powered by PHP Powered by mySQL

All text on this site is © Joe D 2001-08, except where stated, see this page for conditions of use.

Google PageRank Checker - Page Rank Calculator

0.081639051437378 secs